Home Prices in Underhill, Wisconsin (2026)

Based on 19 recent sales in Underhill and the surrounding area:

MEDIAN SALE PRICE
$175,000
Average price$173,795
Price per sq ft$0/sqft
Range$51,900 – $299,900

Top recent sales in Underhill

AddressPriceBeds/BathsSq ft
6017 COUNTY RD V Underhill, Town of$299,9003BR/?BA?
13279 MORGAN Road Underhill, Town of$267,0003BR/?BA?
6899 COUNTY ROAD R Underhill, Town of$220,000?BR/?BA?
5738 BERRY LAKE Road Underhill, Town of$219,9002BR/?BA?
6482 FUST Road Underhill, Town of$210,0003BR/?BA?
14393 WARRINGTON LAKE Lane Underhill, Town of$199,9003BR/?BA?
6285 SHERRIE Lane Underhill, Town of$195,0003BR/?BA?
6973 RED BANKS Road Underhill, Town of$185,5002BR/?BA?

Renovation costs in Underhill

Contractor pricing (REI Renovations / Fox Cities rates):

Kitchen remodel$8,500 – $25,000
Bathroom remodel$4,200 – $12,000
Full renovation$35 – $75 / sqft

Nearby markets

Oshkosh · Green Bay · Wausau · Fond du Lac · Appleton · Sheboygan

Get a free AI estimate for your projectfree estimator · mortgage calc · rehab ROI
Courses → /courses/ · Sell a property → /sell/
📬 Get FRIDAY's weekly market intelligence — free.

Data from FRIDAY's real sold-comps and contractor material pricing. Figures are market data, not an appraisal.