Home Prices in New Holstein, Wisconsin (2026)

Based on 86 recent sales in New Holstein and the surrounding area:

MEDIAN SALE PRICE
$190,000
Average price$188,842
Price per sq ft$0/sqft
Range$50,000 – $292,000

Top recent sales in New Holstein

AddressPriceBeds/BathsSq ft
2232 Illinois AVENUE New Holstein, City of$292,0003BR/?BA?
1814 ILLINOIS Avenue New Holstein, City of$290,0004BR/?BA?
2213 HICKORY Lane New Holstein, City of$280,0003BR/?BA?
2213 Hickory LANE New Holstein, City of$280,0003BR/?BA?
1811 Illinois AVENUE New Holstein, City of$265,0003BR/?BA?
2419 Monroe STREET New Holstein, City of$263,0003BR/?BA?
2109 HICKORY Lane New Holstein, City of$260,0003BR/?BA?
2315 Hickory LANE New Holstein, Town of$260,0003BR/?BA?

Renovation costs in New Holstein

Contractor pricing (REI Renovations / Fox Cities rates):

Kitchen remodel$8,500 – $25,000
Bathroom remodel$4,200 – $12,000
Full renovation$35 – $75 / sqft

Nearby markets

Oshkosh · Green Bay · Wausau · Fond du Lac · Appleton · Sheboygan

Get a free AI estimate for your projectfridaysovereign.com/tools/estimate/
Market courses → /courses/ · Weekly intelligence → /newsletter/

Data from FRIDAY's real sold-comps and contractor material pricing. Figures are market data, not an appraisal.